Source
Saturday, April 3, 2010
Boston Globe opinion piece on "Remember Me"
"Coasting on the Fumes of a Common Cultural Response?" by Ty Burr, Globe staff
Fair warning: If you haven’t seen the current Robert Pattinson movie, “Remember Me,’’ and don’t want the twist ending spoiled, do not read any further. This entire article is a spoiler. Are we clear on that? OK, let’s go.
The reason the film’s ending merits discussion — really, more than the rest of “Remember Me,’’ an intensely mopey saga of young love in Manhattan — is that it uses a major historical event in a way that deeply moves some audiences while deeply offending others. (I’m serious: If you don’t want to know what happens, stop now. The exit’s that way.) And it raises the question once again of when — and how, and if — disaster can or should be repurposed for our entertainment.
Here’s how the finale plays out (last chance, bye-bye): Pattinson’s character, a twitchily misunderstood New York University student named Tyler, has been wrestling with his love for fellow student Ally (Emilie de Ravin) over the course of the film, and things are finally looking up. He has made peace with her cop father (Chris Cooper) and even with his own dad, an imperious Master of the Universe type played by Pierce Brosnan. We’re in New York City at an indeterminate time, although if you’ve been paying close attention, you’ll know exactly what year it is.
Tyler drops by his father’s office one morning for a meeting; dad is running late because the ice around his heart has finally melted and he’s taking his young daughter (Ruby Jerins) to school. Tyler looks at dad’s screensaver — a family slide-show — and is filled with love for the world. He steps to the window. Cut to the sister’s classroom, where the teacher is writing the date on the board: September 11, 2001. Cut back to Tyler at the window; the camera pulls back for the big reveal. He’s high up in one of the World Trade Center towers. Quick montage of shocked faces looking up, a shot of a funeral, Ally carrying on, and roll the credits. Now do you feel sorry for him?
It’s obvious why the filmmakers — screenwriter William Fetters, director Alan Coulter — chose to use 9/11. The tactic validates the characters and their dramas by suddenly reframing them within the context of a historical tragedy that carries agreed-upon cultural significance. By borrowing our emotions about that day, “Remember Me’’ seeks to inflate the meaning of the rest of its story.
And it seems to work, at least for some people. During the movie’s press screening the week before it opened, my colleague Wesley Morris and other local critics sat there with jaws agape and steam coming out their ears even as the smattering of college journalists present wept quietly into their notebooks. Go to the Internet Movie Database, and you’ll find dozens of user reviews lauding the final sequence as “unexpected and very tastefully done,’’ “a beautiful and gentle reminder that 9-11 was about people.’’ (A few naysayers have chimed in on the message boards: “I don’t know if I can ever think of a more manipulative ending solely designed to try and get girls to cry. It was pandering at a level I cannot even think of a reasonable comparison for.’’)
All right, people are moved by what they’re moved by and offended by what they’re offended by — these are honest reactions all. And I honestly know where I stand as a moviegoer: The twist in “Remember Me’’ sickens me. It doesn’t ennoble the characters, it cheapens history, and it abuses my personal memories of the event. Yet I’m open to the fact that others can feel differently, and if I don’t quite understand how, I’m willing to entertain the why of it.
For instance: Is this a matter of age? Although not all the online praise for the movie is coming from the under-30 contingent, a sizable chunk of fans are college age and younger. An 18-year-old would have been 9 when the towers fell, a 21-year-old 12. A 15-year-old “Twilight’’ fan would have been 6, the age I was when John F. Kennedy was shot, which maybe explains why I don’t feel the same measure of disgust for Oliver Stone’s “JFK.’’ National catastrophes experienced in our youth are generalized into frozen images and recollections of grown-ups crying; they don’t happen to us in any way we can conceptualize because they happen when we’re pre-conceptual.
Is it a matter of physical distance? If you processed 9/11 solely through the media coverage, it remains a distant horror made of shared fragments of sound and vision. Because I was living in Brooklyn then, because I just missed seeing the second tower hit as I walked to the corner after voting in the mayoral primary, because my children watched the towers fall from their classroom across New York Harbor, because my older daughter came home clutching a charred memo that had blown across the water, because the air smelled of burning electrical insulation for weeks, because people I knew lost people they knew — because of these and countless other unique memories, the event is a private grieving ground for me even as I share it with millions of others who were closer and farther away.
To not want those experiences whipped into an all-purpose multiplex fiction may be illogical, but we’re not talking about logic here. We’re talking about watching 2,752 individual human beings perish from a close distance. (For that reason, the only 9/11 movie that for this writer carries any weight is the 2002 HBO documentary “In Memoriam: New York City,’’ which is mostly a collage of footage that re-creates the day as it occurred, along with a handful of interviews. At one point, Rudy Giuliani notes that “we’re going to have to remember September 11 in its reality’’ if we don’t want to “rob people of the ability to relive it,’’ an observation that goes a long way in explaining why “Remember Me’’ bugs me so much.)
Which leads to the next consideration: Is it a matter of temporal distance, of time? Even civic and national wounds heal; even psychic scars fade. Three days after the attacks, I wrote in a blog post for my then-employer, Entertainment Weekly, “Entertainment itself suddenly seems obscene. . . . Warner Brothers has indefinitely put off releasing the new Arnold Schwarzenegger terrorism thriller, ‘Collateral Damage.’ Better they should throw the whole project in the dumpster; I can’t think of a genre that now seems more pathetically out of touch than the he-man demolition fest purveyed by actors like Arnold and directors like Michael Bay. Seriously, would you ever, ever want to watch things blow up for the fun of it again?’’
Feel free to laugh in my face. “Collateral Damage’’ came out the following February and made $40 million; Bay’s “Transformers: Revenge of the Fallen’’ was the biggest hit of last summer. Of course the entertainment-industrial complex rebounded; of course we still watch things blow up for the fun of it, now more neurotically than ever. The human aspect of disaster becomes subsumed by the rhythms of daily life and the slow tick of years. We watch “Titanic’’ precisely to be reminded of the individuality of the men, women, and children who perished at sea in 1912, even as we accept the foregrounding of Kate Winslet and Leonardo DiCaprio as one symbolic story out of thousands. Would we accept a similar love story set in the towers or would we find it distasteful? If so, why do we accept a love story that ends there?
And, of course, the culture is different now, so much faster and more aggressive in the way it slices and repackages our actuality. That said, two silent movies re-creating the sinking of the Titanic were released within months of the disaster: a 35-minute German film called “In Nacht und Eis’’ (recently rediscovered, it can be seen on YouTube) and the lost 10-minute saga “Saved From the Titanic,’’ starring an actual survivor, Dorothy Gibson, wearing the actual gown she had on the night of April 14, 1912.
There are no records of shocked audience responses. There are no surviving records whatsoever. But movies were a novelty then, and the restaging of famous battles and other newsworthy events was common. This was a way to grapple with the tragedy, to see it, not to mention a way for Dorothy Gibson to grab a little fame. 9/11, by contrast, was so widely recorded, so seen, that its iconography was immediate. Because of that the event remains difficult to consider afresh. “Remember Me’’ doesn’t even try, choosing instead to coast on the fumes of our common cultural response.
Is it the way the movie uses 9/11, as a “Twilight Zone’’-style gotcha in a tale of ordinary adolescent madness, that sits like an anvil in my stomach? Stone’s 2006 “World Trade Center’’ is a decent film rather than a great one, but at least it’s about the attacks. Same with Paul Greengrass’s “United 93,’’ the TV movie “Flight 93,’’ and other entries in 2006’s brief “Is It Too Soon?’’ genre. Is it still too soon, though, for a teen-oriented romantic melodrama to use the towers as a narrative punch line? What’s the statute of limitations for crap?
What about 9/11 novels like Don DeLillo’s “Falling Man’’ and Jonathan Safran Foer’s “Extremely Loud and Incredibly Close’’ — do we cut them a break because they represent one artist’s attempt to describe the indescribable rather than a collaborative Hollywood star vehicle? What about the Adam Sandler drama “Reign Over Me,’’ in which it’s revealed that the hero’s depression is due to his family’s death in one of the planes? Fair game or not?
As to that last one, I’d say yes, barely, because Sandler gives an honorable performance while Pattinson gives a terribly busy one, made up of grimaces, shrugs, and other James Dean-derived tics. (De Ravin, by contrast, seems grounded and real.) Ultimately, “Remember Me’’ isn’t about the people we lost on 9/11 at all but about more generic notions of living the full life and appreciating what you’ve got while you’ve got it (and who you’ve got while you’ve got them). Really, the bait-and-switch is right there in the title: Remember me, not them.
Some of us aren’t ready to forget about them just yet.
source
Eingestellt von HYPE um 11:10 PM 0 Kommentare
Labels: Awards, Remember Me
Rob Wins Best Foreign Actor Award
Rob has won for Best Foreign Actor in Russia’s ‘Georges’ awards.
The awards are presented by online movie site kinopoisk.ru.
Our lovely follower @kosh789 says the ceremony was March 31.
‘New Moon’ won for Best Foreign “Drama” (bit odd, but we’ll take it), and it came in at #4 in the category of Top Films of the Year. Kristen also won for Best Foreign Actress.
Best part for us.. learning how to spell Robert Pattinson in Russian: Congratulations Роберт Паттинсон!
Eingestellt von HYPE um 11:09 PM 0 Kommentare
Labels: Awards, Robert Pattinson
More New Pictures of Rob filming Bel Ami Yesterday
Eingestellt von HYPE um 11:08 PM 0 Kommentare
Labels: Bel Ami, On the Set, Pictures, Videos
2 great videos of Rob filming Bel Ami today
Source
Eingestellt von HYPE um 11:04 PM 0 Kommentare
Labels: Behind the Scenes, Bel Ami, On the Set, Pictures, Videos
Robert Pattinson on Fans, Fame and Fighting.
By Alan Drake
Eingestellt von HYPE um 10:59 PM 0 Kommentare
Labels: Interview, Robert Pattinson
Out of the Vampires Shadow
Eingestellt von HYPE um 10:56 PM 0 Kommentare
Labels: Interview, Robert Pattinson
NEW Pictures of Rob on the Bel Ami Set - Monday, March 29th
Eingestellt von HYPE um 10:55 PM 0 Kommentare
Labels: Bel Ami, On the Set, Pictures
New Eclipse Paperback Covers
Click for bigger
Pre-order: Here | Here
Via LovingRob
Eingestellt von HYPE um 10:51 PM 0 Kommentare
Labels: Book Cover, Eclipse
Onset March 29th, 2010 [hq/untagged]
Eingestellt von HYPE um 10:49 PM 0 Kommentare
Labels: Bel Ami, HQ Pictures, On the Set
Hello Magazine Poll - Rob pitched against Taylor
Eingestellt von HYPE um 10:45 PM 0 Kommentare
Labels: Poll, Robert Pattinson
Another video from Sunday
Eingestellt von HYPE um 10:42 PM 0 Kommentare
Labels: Bel Ami, On the Set, Videos
OK! Magazine Mexico Interviews Rob - Scans + Translation
Translation
What’s thw first thing you say to a girl on a date?
I don’t talk about myself, no way. You can’t show yourself too quickly. You have to find out what she likes before you start talking.
How can they win your heart?
With money!
Anything else?
Infinite pacience.
What do you hate about fame?
I get paranoid; I have to be careful and try to tell who genuienly likes me, and who wants to be with me just so I like them.
And how can you tell if you can trust them?
If you give them your number and they call you right away, you can’t trust them. If they can’t wait to call and call you the very next day, I don’t want to know about them anymore (laughs).
You seem like a hostage of your own success. Would you prefer to go back to the days when you were unknown?
No, if I had that sort of mentality, I would go nuts. It’s annoying to see how people will stop at nothing. You learn a lot about human behavior. It gets irritating. But I wouldnever want to go back to the past.
Where do you live in America?
I’ve been staying in hotels for that past three years.
Photo. About Mexico city, a place he visited for less than 48 hours while promoting Twilight he said: “I’ve never seen anything like it. In every city there’s an industrial zone around the airport, and in Mexico city you leave the airport and the entire city is just right there, and it’s immediatly vibrant. I’ve never seen such an active city, I really liked it. Wouldn’t mind living there for a while.
What’s it like to live in hotels all the time?
You get tired. I came close to buying a house in America last year, but I realized it would’ve been very complicated. Too much money and I’m not even sure I’ll work there in the next few years.
What makes you feel at home when you travel for a long time?
I always take my guitar with me. I’ve had it for a few years, but I got a new one recently. I like Skype, it’s amazing how you can communicate with everyone no matter where they are. I used to like the feeling of isolation.I used to leave for a year and not talk to anybody. When I came back to London I realized that your life can collapse if you don’t talk to anybody.
In the beginning I thought I could play him close to myself, but it ended up being a different character.
Are you close to your sisters like your character is to his sister?
Yes, very. My sister Liz is older than me, so it’s a bit different. I always wanted a younger sibling. I like working with younger people. Ruby will be amazing when she grows up. She’s so natural in front of the camera. I’ve never worked with anyone as good as her, she’s amazing at improvising and no matter what you say, she doesn’t break character.
Have you ever felt the aggression that Tyler has against life?
I still feel it. It’s an inexplicable anger that’s not directed to anyone in particular. I was never a rebel, but I am now. I always wanted to live like Tyler.
And how do you channel that anger? Do you trash hotel rooms?
Yes, of course. I destroy everything (laughs).I like to control my anger and I channel it throug my work. I’m working on something that requires a lot of angerand it’s exhausting (Bel Ami). I can’t be angry all day, it’s exhausting.
Remember Me talks about how frail life really is. Could you say good-bye to this world right now and be satisfied with what you’ve done?
Yes, in many ways Remember Me talks about how you can achieve happiness. Those brief instants when you realize and say: “Right now, I’m happy”, and how you can live that moment. There’s very few moments like that.
Have you had any of those moments?
Of course I have. Sometimes I’m obsessed with the idea. I can almost time each of these moments, until I feel something else. Those are true moments if peace.
Any moment you can share with us?
When my dog Patty was dying, seeing how she lived her last moments with absolute dignity. That unbreakable pride in her, and her love for me made me feel very happy. She was a big part of the family.
Pierce Brosnan says you have a vey good heart and that you’re humble.
Well, thank you. It’s scary, honestly. I never take fame for granted. It’s not a matter of luck, you have to earn. And somehow I feel like I’ll have to make up for it in the future.
Did you enjoy working with Emilie?
Her role was written as a Hispanic girl from Queens, and I had pictured that in mind already. And all of a sudden the blondest most Australian girl I had ever seen walks in. There’s a toughness about her. After her auditions we went to a bar and she had like 25 beers without losing her sobriety. And I thought “this is going to be fun”.
Scans and Translation: TwilightPoison
Eingestellt von HYPE um 10:34 PM 0 Kommentare
Labels: Interview, Magazines, Robert Pattinson, Scans
Affiliates
Leser
Labels
- Adorable (1)
- Advertising (5)
- Alex Meraz (2)
- Alice Cullen (2)
- Allen Coulter (1)
- Anna Kendrick (2)
- Another Man Magazine (2)
- Art (2)
- Article (46)
- Ashley Greene (28)
- Audio (2)
- Awards (49)
- AWW (1)
- Backstage (1)
- BAFTA Awards (1)
- Behind the Scenes (26)
- Bel Ami (72)
- Bella and Edward (75)
- Bella Swan (2)
- Billy Burke (4)
- Book Cover (1)
- Box Office (17)
- Breaking Dawn (20)
- Bronson Pelletier (1)
- Bryce Dallas Howard (1)
- Calendar (1)
- Calvin Klein (9)
- Cedrig Diggory (2)
- Charity (27)
- Charlie Bewley (4)
- Chris Cooper (1)
- Chris Weitz (59)
- Christine Hardwicke (1)
- Christmas (2)
- Comic Book (2)
- Comic Con (1)
- Contest (2)
- Convention (1)
- Cover (2)
- Coverage (2)
- Cullens (2)
- Dakota Fanning (3)
- Daniel Cudmore (3)
- Daniel Radcliffe (1)
- David Slade (1)
- Download (3)
- DVD (46)
- DVD Spots (1)
- Eclipse (197)
- Eclipse Cast (1)
- Eclipse Page (2)
- Edward Cullen (110)
- Elizabeth Reaser (8)
- Emilie de Ravin (48)
- Emmett (1)
- Emmett Cullen (8)
- Estimate (3)
- Event (1)
- Extended Scenes (1)
- Family Pattinson (1)
- Fanpictures (16)
- Fansite (1)
- Fanvideo (1)
- Footage (3)
- Galleries (1)
- Games (1)
- giggles (1)
- Gil Birmingham (1)
- Giveaway (2)
- Go ahead and cook meself a coffee (1)
- Halloween (3)
- Harper's Bazaar (2)
- Harry Potter Cast (2)
- HOLY SH** (79)
- How to be (19)
- HQ Pictures (110)
- Immortals (2)
- Information (35)
- Interview (708)
- It's a wrap (1)
- Jackson Rathbone (8)
- Jacob (14)
- Jacob and Bella (1)
- Jamie Cambell Bower (2)
- Javier Beltran (1)
- Jennie Garth (1)
- Kellan Lutz (207)
- Kellectrified (115)
- Kola (3)
- Kristen Prout (2)
- Kristen Stewart (174)
- Little Ashes (10)
- Little Robby (1)
- LoL (1)
- Magazines (264)
- Making Of (2)
- Merchandise (17)
- Meskada (3)
- Michael Sheen (2)
- Midnight Sun (1)
- Modeling (3)
- Movies (7)
- MTV (13)
- MTV Awards (3)
- Musicvideo (1)
- New Moon (277)
- New Moon Promo (43)
- New Moon Soundtrack (3)
- New Moon Stills (3)
- Nicole Kidman (1)
- Nikki Reed (16)
- NoES (1)
- Nominations (4)
- Nylon (2)
- Oh Cedric (8)
- Oh my Edward (1)
- OMG (1)
- On the Set (43)
- Outtake (4)
- Outtakes (19)
- Ouw my Robert (1245)
- p (1)
- Paul (1)
- PeTA (1)
- Peter Facinelli (9)
- Photocall (24)
- Photoshoots (98)
- Pictures (76)
- Pierce Brosnan (14)
- Podcast (1)
- Poll (113)
- Poster (2)
- Premiere (35)
- Premieres (2)
- PreOrder (1)
- Press Conferences (60)
- Press Junket (48)
- Promo (5)
- Promo Pictures (4)
- Promo Stills (1)
- Public Appearances (212)
- QandA (1)
- Quiz (1)
- Rachel Weisz (1)
- Rachelle Lefevre (1)
- Radio (1)
- Radio Interview (5)
- Release Date (4)
- Remember Me (303)
- Remember Me Team (7)
- Respect Robert (2)
- Review (31)
- Robert Pattinson (1382)
- Robert Pattinsont (3)
- Ruby Jerins (8)
- Rupert Grint (1)
- Sad Panda (1)
- Scans (225)
- Scene it (1)
- Screens (4)
- Sneak Peek (16)
- Snippets (3)
- Soundtrack (10)
- Spoiler-Alert (35)
- Stephenie Meyer (3)
- Stills (61)
- Taylor Lautner (136)
- Teaser Trailer (4)
- Tess of the D’Urbervilles (1)
- The Badmother's Handbook (6)
- The Goblet of Fire (1)
- The Haunted Airman (7)
- The Summer House (10)
- To act for oneself (4)
- Tokyo (1)
- Tom Felton (1)
- TradingCards (1)
- Trailer (19)
- TV Spot (8)
- TwiCon (12)
- Twilight (39)
- Twilight Cast (98)
- Twitter (1)
- Tyler Hawkins (2)
- uhm like whut (47)
- Unbound Captives (4)
- UNF (48)
- Untagged (1)
- Vanity Fair (20)
- Videos (394)
- Volturi (19)
- Volvo (3)
- Vote (25)
- Wallpaper (2)
- Water for Elephants (11)
- WAX (5)
- Win (1)
- Wolf Pack (9)
- Wolves Wolves Wolves (3)